Why don't we just lynch him? :p

Vote ViolatorX

I've already investigated you and there's nothing to say whether you're scum or not. Makes more sense to lynch you now and investigate ViolatorX.

That's not a bad idea actually; only one of us can die overnight, so we're guaranteed to get one successful power role usage (assuming of course that we're both town). I'm torn between hammering ViolatorX and voting elbaz at the moment ... It doesn't actually matter either way; if we lynch elbaz, I'll block ViolatorX and if we lynch ViolatorX, I'll block eyeball226.

ViolatorX stated earlier that he'd be home around 12 (an hour and a half from now), so I'll at least grant him the courtesy to have his say, I think.

Yeah ok, if we do lynch ViolatorX feel free to roleblock me since there'll be no use for my power and it'll help clear me (if there's a night kill).

I think it'd still be better to lynch Elbaz and, since there are a couple of votes on ViolatorX: vote Elbaz.

@Nmillar
You like everyone seem to neglet perhaps he was telling the truth about the 4 mafia and they are divided into 2 groups of 2, given all the power roles it would make a lot of sense in the activity.

You instead of targeting who you think is guilty target someone completely random just reeks of scum, It just makes no sense and has no purpose of protecting in the interests of the town which as a roleblocker is surely your duty

I just cant believe noone else can see through the lies, Day 1 your target conviently died, day 2 you target GQ and after nailing her to the wall she dies, now day 3 you have another suspect block in robbeasy when seems suspiciously random and slightly hipocritical considering you slander eyeball for doing the same thing if you were town you would have blocked your likely suspect

I just also dont see there being a Jailer and a Roleblocker on the town, I think your are lying in some capacity especially in night 2 with there being no kills it doesnt add up.

@Robbeasy
If I was lieing why would I even mention it in the 1st place?, It serves to give me no advantage to even mention me slipping of the counter, Its already been claimed by nmillar of all people he recieved the same info, either him being truthful or just using my text to further protect himself.

If I was a killer surely I for one wouldnt tell you a summary of the flavor I recieved, I would have swept it under the carpet and dismissed it entirely.

If I wasnt roleblocked what was I? What else would stop me from visiting you?

@Eyeball
Lets say you are being honest and are just extremely unlucky in your selections, Your scan of andy being a false Im sure would happen as he he would have had some form of protection like a mafia godfather placed into his role to make it slightly easier to stay alive as he would be at a huge disadvantage being a sole person trying to win the game, It seems again people like to overlook the obvious here.

@elbaz - I never thought you were even slightly scummy till you just jumped in without any prior justification especially with the whole day being peoples arguements for and against, It just seems that you will jump on any bandwagon to keep you alive. I also find is suspicious that ghost had you nailed to the wall and you walked away scot free the next day.

I think nmillar would be the logical choice to lynch(after all his roleblocking is dangerous if he is mafia) but after elbazs rather cheap vote I'd hammer him as well

Im going to get blocked, investigated and probably every other power thrown at me tomorrow anyway so it makes little difference who out of eyeball,nmillar and elbaz I vote for .Just bear in mind when I flip town someone else less in the firing line will have more chance of a scum win as Im sure there will be another kill tonight. I always find this I'll happily die to save the town theory either lies of poor play as dieing in my eyes anyway seems like an automatic loss.

Regardless elbaz's vote bears the least weight and logic through the day and looks like hes scoring a quick lynch so Vote Elbaz but would rather drop the hammer on nmillar regardless

I've figured it out.

Night 1: andy433uk killed Red_Baron, mafia killed Vitek, who may not have been the original target, but died protecting someone.

Night 2: mafia targeted andy433uk, but he was bulletproof. andy433uk's target also survived. ViolatorX protected that target. My role block was on GhostQlyph, which proves there's another protector role in play.

Night 3: andy433uk killed TwilightBard. Mafia killed andy433uk.

Vote elbaz.

No, you win if your side wins. Being out of the game and losing are different things.

I think I've understood your sentence correctly but I'm not entirely sure (don't mean to be a dick, but punctuation is helpful sometimes).

I will be role blocking ViolatorX tonight if the game isn't over beforehand.

All of this post has no relevance to the game as that line was just a general opinion of gameplay.

I apologise I was in a bit of a rush as I said I would have posted and time was getting on so I typed the last 10 lines without even looking at the screen.

I fail to see the logic when people like ghost did in this game came out with, I'll happily die to prove im innocent. Being a martyr really doesnt achieve anything in my eyes. It also looks suspect as who would willingly put their head on the block? the whole point of the game being to find the baddies and not get killed as a member of town.

Im aware we win as a town when all factions are eliminated, but imo it seems cheap to win something If you have been killed. Lets face it who would willing to DIE to prove a point and you cant celebrate anyway, as your either 6 feet under, in a jar on the mantlepiece or stuffed in a body bag (Yes its obviously a game but still) I would consider dieing to be a loss, Unless of course I have a role aiming to kept myself killed.

Mafia is a great game to play but that machanic just bugs me

Well, I think I've been lynched so this hardly matters, but I do have to wonder at the logic of lynching someone you're not sure of (indeed many have basically concluded that I'm most assuredly town) and investigating the person that, apparently, most seem to think is more likely to be mafia. My vote on Violator was more in exasperation at this strange tactic than anything.

I wonder if we're all going to regret allowing nmillar to essentially run the show. Despite a good deal of scummy behavior, he has not only avoided lynching but, particularly in the latter game, controlled the conversation expertly. Therefore, as a symbolic protest:

unvote violatorX, vote nmillar

I actually hope I'm wrong, because if he is mafia, we're in deep trouble. Long live the townie appliances!

The "Revenge of the Appliances" votecount

ViolatorX - 1 - Robbeasy
elbaz - 3 - eyeball226, ViolatorX, nmillar
nmillar - 1 - elbaz

A total of 5 votes.

It is now twilight, standby for lynch scene. Discussion may continue until nightfall.

I'm baking at the moment. Anyone want a slice of humble pie? :P

Ok, so we'll roleblock/investigate ViolatorX and see what happens in the morning?

That's the plan, but I'm pretty sure the game has just finished.

*fingers crossed*

Has there been a town win in any of the games so far (haven't been paying attention at all).