I sure hope there is only one scum left. As the 2nd would only be guesswork...

I'm sure I know nothing about that.

Yes and I was awake thinking of how the everyone else lynched the cop.

@cristi Wow, that's extreme.

those 2 D1 cop-claims did not do much to benefit town

At least we know their investigations. Could be worse, they could have died before revealing anything. And with 2 NK's, that wasn't too unlikely.

Town got 2 doctors and 2 cops, I think it would be unfair to mafia if there was only 1 traitor and 1 strongman in it. There's surely 2 more mafia alive.

I believe flub to be town because a miller makes a lot of sense with 3 investigatory roles in the game. I believe RW is town because of reasons already explained. I know I'm town. That leaves you, cristi, and krypsyn. What do you think the liklihood of krypsyn being mafia is? Cristi?

Really? We are talking 2 doctors who apparently can't protect anyone and two cops who read everything wrong...
Even with a virtually guaranteed mislynch from the false reads? And a very likely follow-up mislynch of the cop who revealed...

I'm certainly not convinced there are two scum, but cannot rule it out.

I also think flub pushed hunter as mafia because he knew he was a miller and knew there were 2 cop claims and that they made sense given his role and so he also knew their reads were suspect/probably wrong, and so figured hunter for mafia pretty quickly

Cristi seems clean to me after those posts she did above and Krypsyn seems to match with his commuter thing with his hiding places. That only leaves you, rw and flub. My favs are you and flub, although I'd like to lynch flub today.

However it does occur to me that miller maybe doesn't make sense given the weak state of the cops already and could be a false claim.

Hunter - I rather expected they would. bler indicated that scum would have a way to counteract the event that we figured out how to break the game. Perhaps that has something to do with it.

I'm Town Surgeon. Why would we have Town Backup Surgeon and no Town Surgeon?

Knowing what I do, why are we still in the game? Why was there no other kill last night? I'm not aware of having any type of protection (scum tried to kill me and they failed). Actually, that would have been a decent lie. If I was lying about all this, i would have come up with something that made more sense than this. I know I look guilty.

It's possible that my 'protection' of Bookwyrn happened before scum attempted their kill, so it wasn't necessary, or we couldn't tell there was overkill.

What was the BANG about? Was the whole thing, shot and all, part of my delusion? I have a lots of questions, not many answers.

I think the starting place should be obvious...

or maybe (one of?) the bastard element(s) is mafia doesn't know they are mafia, and you are killing unknowingly and are actually mafia?