Hello,

I was getting a game from the Twitch prime page. I had forgot about having an account already. So I went through and used my email and it let me do it to create the account. Now I have two accounts with the same email and two games that are separated now.

When I contacted support the answer I got back was "This isn't possible to do". I have screenshot proof that this did happen and Twitch/GOG allowed me to do it. I am not sure what to do so the game goes to the "correct" account with my email.

Did you use Facebook to create that other account / log in by any chance?

I didn't. I just used the create account link going from Twitch and it didn't stop me from using the same email.