Hi fellow gogers,
I want to buy one of the games mentioned in topic, but I can decide what one. I know that this is like to ask what is better apple or orange? But all I am asking from you is to tell me your opinions why and what game is better.

red dead. by far

Red Dead Redemption. It's an awesome game. Detailed, authentic world, lots of random stuff to do and a great story with some really nice missions as well.
Modnation is good fun too, but only if you are planning to play MP a lot. The weapons can be a bit annoying.

I'd have to agree, RDR is simply awesome in spite of a few bugs. Multiplayer is great fun and the single player story is huge and well told

Thanks everybody for help everybody will pick up Red Dead when it will be available :)

RDR By far is great, but pick up Mod when it goes on sale :) It is an immensly fun multiplayer game (kinda like Mario Kart for the Wii but more modding)

Hows the track creation? I've not seen that much on it other than the new kevin butler ad

I have not tooled with it, but my woman friend (the term girlfriend just seems odd... I mean... im not dating a teenager.... ) She's made a few tracks so far, some are pretty good... im thinking ill tool around with it at a later point... but for now... ive just got to many games and not enough time.....

The term is very dangerous for a lasting relationship. Much easier to "break up" with someone, both in your mind and actual, when he is your man friend, than boyfriend. And yes, the term can be used even when neither is a teenager.
Although there are other words too like f*buddy etc.
Modnation strikes me as a weird game and not the good type of weird. I don't know if it was just me, but playing the demo I felt the camera to be way too close to the kart and the fov on the side way too small.

Does that problem ever go away?