Didn't we already have this talk back when RPS covered it?

Yes, we did. I think the conclusions back then were:
"It looks like shit"
"It sounds like they don't know what they're talking about"
"The voice-over guy sounds really creepy"
"It'll take up massive amounts of HDD space"
"Let's wait and see, there's not enough information to say anything conclusive"
That's from memory, you understand, so it may not be entirely accurate.

I had an inkling I'd seen this video before, but couldn't quite place where. So it was at RPS.......

Found the thread.

Now I feel foolish D:

Well, it was hard to find. I searched the forum for "unlimited detail", and there it was ;-p

That was me!

You win Oscar, bro!

Uhm, yes? I didn't specify who said what, I just listed the points made in the thread, as well as I could remember them at the time. Sorry if you feel left out ;-)

heh, can I be the GOG forum's resident bro?

*boxes captfitz' fist*

DONE. scope my new forum title.

Brotasticular, bro.

I changed my title too. Brotastic!