Made a mistake, forgot that scum only gets 1 kill per night. Played a non-standard game before so I was stuck in that mindset. Just curious which subject?

I doubted the even odd thing.

No I meant which subject are you a teacher of, flavor wise? I understood what you said in 585.

lol I was a little surprised by the question.
I teach Logistics.

@Leo - if you were not scum - who would be your three highest scum suspects?

I should've framed that question better. Asked just to see what kind of subjects are out there.

They were analytical and wordy before or they aren't like that now?

You touched other stuff I said but missed one that I find important. What would you say about this:

I wouldn't say they're all that analytical and wordy now. They are more than earlier in the game because it's day 3 now. It doesn't have anything to do with CSPVG being a lynch candidate.


First of all I'm not certain he's scum. However between the two of Hunter and Dessimu, one of whom I think is scum, I find Dessimu a little scummier.
As for earlier, I wasn't convinced those people were scum was I?
The only person I really feel is scum is flub, thus my vote.

You know, I really miss trentonlf, cristigale and HypersomniacLive in here. I know they said they have certain things to do, places to be... I am not saying they are mafia for not being here now. I am just expressing my general feeling that in this situation it would be nice if they were in here to share their insightful opinions.

@leonard Why do you keep doubting flub when no cop counterclaim has been made in all this time?

For the moment (as in "until/unless proven wrong"), your suspicion and vote on flubbucket looks more like mafia acting in a way "If we are not sure we can night kill flubbucket, lets try to lynch him instead".

Sorry, I somehow missed this.
Top picks would be:
flub, Dessimu (because I think flub covering for one of you two), and then either CSPVG or dedo.

I just... don't believe him. He's seemed scummy to me the whole game.

I don't think there's anything I can do to stop that. It's not true though.

Bitch, they might be :P

I'm not particularly sold on that one as well. It does help a lot that there is no counter claim but that doesn't automatically mean the claim isn't false. We have a very fresh example of a false cop claim without a counter that pretty much everyone took in without thinking twice and that ended up being the winning play for scum.


By the way, please refrain from hammering Leonard a bit longer, so others have time to chime in. And I do think it's a good idea for flub to align with the rest of us who will be checked tonight to make Tomorrow's read (if there is one) just a bit safer and leave less wiggle room.


So these three would have been your top picks if were not scum?

You get a consensus and I'll play along.

Since I'm not scum, those are my picks.