One hour to go vote count...
7 Trentonlf (JMich, HypersomniacLive, McHack, Adaliabooks, Cristigale, Dedoporno, HijacK)
1 (Lifthrasil)
1 Adaliabooks (Trentonlf)

Trentonlf would be leaving the island....
Update coming...

JMich and flub voted for me also

Final vote count...
7.5 Trentonlf (JMich, HypersomniacLive, McHack, Adaliabooks, Cristigale, Dedoporno, HijacK) .............................................................................................................. .............................................and a late Flubbucket
1 (Lifthrasil)
1 Adaliabooks (Trentonlf)

Trentonlf is leaving the island....
Update coming...

Bagatha Chrustie here....
Finally the housemates have made a decision and chose Trentonlf to evict...
Trenton pays up his $10,000 entry fee....
He was Harry [Houdini] (Neutral Pickpocket)

I think it's a bad idea to grant adalia that role, since it's indeed a foul way to break the game (with yogs strategy you could've just played along as scum seeing as so many others did)
I mean adalia could've just come out and claimed scum and wished for someone to claim that role in his first post and the game would be over ... at least it would be nice if he had a restriction (or only x-shot lynchproof?) so the game can continue
also trent was already hammered when it all happened, so I don't think he can really stop the lynch now, right?

At this point I'm going to call it....
Adaliabooks dies in his sleep (someone knows why)
BlueMooner dies of old age (lack of posting for 3 straight game days - Friday, Monday and Tuesday)
That completes the scum team...

The reason Adalia's claim did not work is because it came after the clinching lynch vote, I had mentioned this in a clarification in the scum thread early on. It was close, but even then Adalia would have only gotten those abilities as one-shots...

Victory :D !?!!

So let's talk about the setup...
You had 10 town, 4 scum and two Neutral roles...
Town all had restrictions, and scum did have a re-restrictor...
But Trenton's neutral role was active.

I felt this was balanced because with so many players and no serial killer, there were going to be plenty of days of vote analysis to rely on and even just a few roles unlocked should be enough. Plus, all scum roles except Adalia's could be role copped.

So a few things went poorly...the random draw placed the two new players in the most important roles in the game...
McHack as the Self-Help Guru and BlueMooner as the "Intimidator".
McHack played great and BlueMooner did fine before disappearing. The problem was that in the Night 0 scum chat, BlueMooner didn't realize the significance of his role and told his buddies he was just a Role Blocker. I had expected that information to be shared and in combination with the Sample PM, scum should have had equal chances of figuring out the setup as town.

Well, that kind of sucks for me, but congrats to town. Was hoping with the early scum kills I might convince town to grant my win condition in the coming days. I was Neutral no-lynch. Made some sort of bet before coming on the island. Had to get half of the players to vote no-lynch in order to win.

Of course, even with this detriment, I think scum had a good chance, but then you drop CSPVG on pure chance and Krypsyn made a hasty vote on HijacK. Now, a lot of the setup was to partially penalize town for early claiming. Reveal your Gurus and scum kills them, your investigative roles are minimized and it gives scum the chance to slip someone into the end game. And reveal too early and Adalia claims one of your roles and hopefully gets confirmed...

So there were also two neutral roles. They were not survivors though. One was Trentonlf (one of the 4 Pickpockets in the game) whose win condition was to amass $50,000.

The other was Cristigale, the toughest role to win, needed to convince town to "no-lynch" to win a "bet with a friend".

Thank you Rwarehall. Despite Trent being not so happy, I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed the game!

huh, and bluemooner was even in the get it group until he speculated too much and did his 180. I could've "unrestricted" him :) the horror :P

oh and out of curiosity, what was your role now, flubbucket?

Your failure will long be remembered in harrowing detail. Or at least, vaguely recollected until the next game starts.

I was not unhappy with the game, I thought the game had a great setup. I was not happy about the PM info coming out day 1 the way it did, it broke the game.

So let's list the roles...
1) Hijack - [Shallow] Hal - Town Reserve Self-Help Guru
2) Trentonlf - Harry [Houdini] - Neutral Pickpocket
3) Adaliabooks - Jerod {The Pretender] - Scum Impersonator
4) JMich - Steve [Irwin] - Town Distracted Watcher
5) HypersomniacLive - Fagin [Oliver Twist] - Town Recovered Pickpocket
6) Flubbucket - John Kruger - Town Regretful Jailkeeper [Yes, he had a last name!]
7) Agentcarr16 - Gregory [House] - Town Traumatized Doctor
8) Lifthrasil - Rudolph [The Reindeer] - Town Distracted Tracker
9) CSPVG - [Gray] Mouser - Scum Pickpocket
10) Yogsloth - [Sgt] Schultz - Town Cop
11) Mchack - Tony [Robbins] - Self-Help Guru
12) Krypsyn - Fezzik - Scum Thug (with One-shot Strongman)
13) Sage103082 - Mathilda [The Professional] - Town Remorseful Vigilante
14) Dedoporno - Angus [MacGuyber] - Town Confused Jack of All Trades {Cop, Doctor, Vigilante and Roleblocker}
15) Cristigale - Judy [Clarke] - Neutral No-Lynch Advocate (detects as vanilla)
16) BlueMooner - Clint [Eastwood] - Scum Intimidator
17) RWarehall - Bruce [Nolan-Almighty] - Town Former God
18) Bagatha Chrustie - Neutral Amateur Pickpocket (always goes last - foiled and detected by other pickpockets; chooses target randomly excluding pickpocket claims)

Wow. Talk about carelessness.

In any case. GG town. This was a fun setup. First 2 days were a thrill.

So there was supposed to be a fair bit of mystery over money as there were 4 Pickpockets about. Bagatha stole from me day 0; chose Flubbucket Day 1, got there and found no money. Then chose Yogsloth Day 2...

You were supposed to eventually figure out she was lynchable and killable...
Yeah, I had considered that the scum might try some sort of post lynch bribe like that. I was also fairly confident that regardless of claim, I could set limitations which were not game-breaking even for crazy claims. My thought was scum would pick a useful role and use it to confirm themselves as town under the idea that I might have one or two unrestricted roles as well...