Sorry for the long explanation - I am trying to link many threads and to be clear. My caution is based on what is being posted in other threads combined with personal job experience in the commercial software field. I am strongly cautioning a "wait and see" on the latest installer-only updates for classic installer only users - until we can see what can be found out or we get a response from GOG.
bjgamer: You may not want to redownload those with installer only updates. The way it looks now, those installer updates are not adding anything to gameplay, only
bundling Galaxy in with the classic installers which increases (bloats in the case of non-Galaxy users) the files.
timppu: Is there some ongoing discussion about that somewhere? I didn't see any mention (nor confirmation) of that in e.g. the "what has been updated" or "adam's WINE wrappers" discussions.
(snip)
Or what exactly did you mean by "bundling Galaxy in with the classic installers"?
Like you I've been watching several threads and putting pieces together.
Here
Question regarding the updated installers they have noted in the installer-only updates there is no change to the included files gameplay-wise, but that there seem to be new shortcuts having to do with Galaxy when the game is launched and some installers have been updated to have the Galaxy installer included.
In
The "what did just update" thread they have noted that "every updated installer has no galaxy installer (anymore)" per Lin545 and "Not a single one of the games I own that has been received an installer updated recently also has an optional Galaxy installer" per MarkoH01.
Putting this together with my own experience as a Software Engineer and Architect, I have worked before at companies that 'package together' installers with hidden directories and files and slip them to the client. In truth, sometimes this is done so as to keep better track of updates and cut down on mistakes. Oftentimes, however, it is to cut down the workload and if done lazily can bloat files and take up more computer resources at the client (users) end. In this particular case I would be fine with language or OS version installers packaged together - but as non-user of Galaxy and an user of adamhm's wine wrappers, WINE, ./play.it who likes mods and modding, these new installers are interfering with what I and some other Gog customers have paid for. I came here to buy and own clean installers, DRM-free. Like many here, I specifically bought games on GOG after researching if they would work with how we wanted to play them (DRM-free, work with specific OS's or mods). It is my choice not to take part in Galaxy. I don't fault those that do wish to, but at this time I do not want Galaxy installer files rearranging things on my personal computer. The concern here is that GOG may be taking that choice away. If those Goggers like myself (who depend on the classic installers for work-arounds) download the new installers many games we already bought may no longer work for us, and we are beyond the refund limit for something GOG sprung on us with no transparency, no warning or announcement of their intent.
If true, that bothers me.
Currently
it looks like this is what is going on, based on what has been put together through several different threads, that GOG may be packaging together the classic and Galaxy installers and the process is also including files and directories which are hidden behind either encryption or obfuscation. I haven't seen it confirmed yet where anyone has exactly found what these do. In various other threads
a few users have reported they downloaded the new installers and the game wouldn't launch, another said some have been found to be corrupted (unconfirmed). I actually don't think GOG intended to 'break' things, and they may have to go back and rework these. At this point I would simply caution those who use the classic installers that they may not wish to download the new installer-only updates until we see if those working on this can find what is truly going on, and/or we hear from GOG what they purpose to do. GOG may have to either change these installer packages again or archive and offer clean classic installers to those of us who need them. At this time I prefer to not buy nor download anything from GOG until we get clear answers.
For those wondering what games are effected:
the what did just update weekly digest is trying to keep track.
For ./play.it or Adamhm’s wrappers users they are offering in the project thread to check if the latest installer of your game is supported.